***In Progress***
Let's talk setting! This book is set in the early 1920's (awesome!) in New York City. The roaring 20's is a fascinating choice. Most YA books set in the past are either 1800's or during a War. There's something about the language usage, style, and people of this time period that is intriguing.
Another reason why I am really happy about this book and its setting is because I know that Mrs. Bray had to actually research in order to create a historically accurate 1926 NYC. This means that she likely poured over books, time period newspapers and magazines, and, of course, the internet. I'm betting she spoke with individuals who lived during the time period. However she came about her information, it wasn't discovered with ease, which I deeply appreciate.
The writing is imaginative and thorough. Even the moments that I really wish I didn't have to vividly picture, I am forced to because of the writing.
Now, this book is a murder mystery with a twisted and disturbing murderer. I personally, do not recommend that my middle schoolers pick it up. As I eluded, the murder scenes are descriptive and basically terrifying.
I also do not recommend this as an audio book. Libba Bray writes a story woven around several characters that interact throughout the novel. When I read a book of this nature, I will often go back to clarify a question I have about a previous story and then flip back to my current place. With an audio book, this becomes extremely difficult and bothersome. I find myself worrying that I am missing a key element, especially when deciphering the murderer's "motives".
After reading my previous post you know that I love magic! This book has it! I will save that for discussion when I reach the book's conclusion.
No comments:
Post a Comment